Motivated explanation
نویسندگان
چکیده
Although motivation is a well-established field of study in its own right, and has been fruitfully studied in connection with attribution theory and belief formation under the heading of "motivated thinking," its powerful and pervasive influence on specifically explanatory processes is less well explored. Where one has a strong motivation to understand some event correctly, one is thereby motivated to adhere as best one can to normative or "epistemic" criteria for correct or accurate explanation, even if one does not consciously formulate or apply such criteria. By contrast, many of our motivations to explain introduce bias into the processes involved in generating, evaluating, or giving explanations. Non-epistemic explanatory motivations, or following Kunda's usage, "directional" motivations, include self-justification, resolution of cognitive dissonance, deliberate deception, teaching, and many more. Some of these motivations lead to the relaxation or violation of epistemic norms; others enhance epistemic motivation, so that one engages in more careful and thorough generational and evaluative processes. We propose that "real life" explanatory processes are often constrained by multiple goals, epistemic and directional, where these goals may mutually reinforce one another or may conflict, and where our explanations emerge as a matter of weighing and satisfying those goals. We review emerging evidence from psychology and neuroscience to support this framework and to elucidate the central role of motivation in human thought and explanation.
منابع مشابه
How Human-like Are “human-like” Type Error Explanations?
We have constructed an explanation system for polymorphic types, motivated by analysis of human type explanations. Qualitative and quantitative comparison of human expert and our computer generated explanations of polymorphic type errors suggests that they are very similar.
متن کاملA simple probabilistic explanation of term frequency-inverse document frequency (tf-idf) heuristic (and variations motivated by this explanation)
متن کامل
A Review of Driver Genetic Alterations in Thyroid Cancers
Thyroid cancer is a frequent endocrine related malignancy with continuous increasing incidence. There has been moving development in understanding its molecular pathogenesis recently mainly through the explanation of the original role of several key signaling pathways and related molecular distributors. Central to these mechanisms are the genetic and epigenetic alterations in these pathways, su...
متن کاملارائه و تبیین مدل انگیزشی مبتنی بر معنویت کارکنان
Motivation at work is a multiple phenomenon which can not be evaluated by a single variable, directly. Motivation at work is concerned with internal and external variables which determine, initiation, form, direction, intensity and duration of the work. Furthermore, personnel’s motivation for work originates from complexity of the individuals’ personalities, nature of the work and the cha...
متن کاملHow to Estimate Forecasting Quality: A System-Motivated Derivation of Symmetric Mean Absolute Percentage Error (SMAPE) and Other Similar Characteristics
When comparing how well different algorithms forecast time series, researchers use an average value of the ratio |x− y| (|x|+ |y|)/2 , known as the Symmetric Mean Absolute Percentage Error (SMAPE). In this paper, we provide a system-motivated explanation for this formula. We also explain how this formula explains the use of geometric mean to combine different forecasts.
متن کامل